
The Gene Almost Nobody Is Testing: Your Hormone Levels Look Normal. Your Clearance May Not Be.
By Lori Finlay, NP, CNS
My friend, let me guess how this went.
You finally got the bloodwork. Estrogen, progesterone, thyroid, maybe even cortisol.
You sat in that paper gown, or on that Zoom call, and heard the words you’ve heard before:
“Everything looks normal.”
And yet.
The breast tenderness still comes and goes with your cycle. Your heart races over a tense email. One cup of coffee leaves you wired until dinner.
And at night you’re bone-tired, but your mind won’t stop replaying the day.
Here is what nobody told you.
A hormone level is a snapshot of how much is in your blood at one moment. It says almost nothing about how well your body clears that hormone once it’s done its job.
Clearing hormones — your hormone metabolism (how your body breaks down and moves hormones out) — is where so many women’s stories actually live.
One gene sits right in the middle of that story.
Almost nobody tests it.

COMT stands for catechol-O-methyltransferase (kuh-TEE-kol oh-METH-il-trans-FUR-ase).
It’s the gene that makes an enzyme (a protein that speeds up a chemical job in your body) with two very important assignments [1]:

Same enzyme. Two jobs.
That’s why the breast tenderness, the anxious edge, the caffeine jitters and the “tired but wired” nights can share one root.
If you read my May post on COMT here, you already know there are faster and slower versions of this gene.
The most studied variant is called Val158Met. People with two “slow” copies (Met/Met) make a COMT enzyme that works noticeably less efficiently, with roughly 40% lower activity in brain tissue in one key study [3].
And if you read last week’s post on your breasts here, you saw how estrogen travels through your liver and gut on its way out.
Today, we zoom in on the checkpoint in the middle.

One thing I’ll always remind you
Whether it’s the estrogen God gave you, man-made (synthetic) estrogen, plant-based estrogens (phytoestrogens, found in foods like soy and flax), or toxic environmental estrogens (xenoestrogens, chemicals from plastics, pesticides and personal care products that act like estrogen in your body):
They ALL have to be processed and cleared out of your body.
Your liver handles the whole load. For your own estrogen and the synthetic kinds, we want as much as possible traveling down the gentler 2-OH road. And here’s the twist: some environmental chemicals actually push estrogen toward the more reactive 4-OH road.
So every outside source you cut adds up. Less in means less to clear.
It’s not a conspiracy. It’s a blind spot.
Standard hormone panels were built to measure how much, not how well.
Genetic variants like COMT aren’t part of routine care. Most insurance plans don’t cover the testing. And many providers were never trained to use the results.
(I wasn’t, in my early nursing years. I learned this on the other side of my own health crisis.)
The good news? Functional medicine providers who run DNA panels do look at COMT. And providers who use the DUTCH test know it matters, because they can often see your COMT story playing out right there in your results.
So a woman can have perfectly “normal” estrogen levels while her body clears used estrogen and stress hormones slowly.
Her labs say fine. Her body says otherwise.
Both are telling the truth, because they’re answering different questions.
This is the part I love, because it turns guesswork into a map.
I connect the dots from three places:
1. Your DNA. A DNA panel shows which version of COMT you carry, along with related genes like MTHFR that feed it. This is your blueprint, and it doesn’t change. I use The DNA Company’s panel because it’s clinically thorough and built to be actionable.
2. Your DUTCH test. The DUTCH test (Dried Urine Test for Comprehensive Hormones) shows your blueprint in action. Beyond your hormone levels, it maps which roads your estrogen is taking — the gentler 2-OH road, the more reactive 4-OH road, or the stronger 16-OH road — and includes a “Methylation Activity” marker that shows how well that COMT tagging step is keeping up.
It also shows your daily cortisol rhythm, which matters a lot when your stress chemistry clears slowly.
3. Your story. Your symptoms, your cycle, your history, what’s worked and what’s backfired. The numbers only make sense next to the woman they belong to.
Put those three side by side, and patterns appear that no single test could show.
That’s not a diagnosis. It’s direction.
Here’s why I care so much about this gene:
The same protocol can help one woman and backfire for another, and COMT is often the reason.
DIM and broccoli extracts. These are popular for “estrogen balance,” and they can push estrogen toward the gentler 2-OH road [4]. But in some slow-COMT women, more catechol estrogens get made than COMT can tag in time, and they feel worse: low mood, achy joints, fatigue. Start low and watch how you feel.
Methylated B vitamins. COMT runs on a methyl donor called SAM (S-adenosylmethionine, your body’s main “methyl” supplier). Some women feel wonderful on methylated B’s. Some slow-COMT women feel anxious and wired on big doses. More isn’t always better.
Caffeine. Research shows people with certain COMT types report a bigger jump in heart rate after caffeine [5]. If one cup leaves you jittery for hours, that may be biology, not willpower.
Magnesium. COMT can’t do its job without magnesium [1]. Low magnesium can slow it down no matter which version you inherited.
I didn’t know my own COMT story until I tested my DNA at 50.
For years, I’d done “everything right,” and protocols barely touched my symptoms.
When I finally saw my genetic picture, it reframed everything:
I was not failing my protocol. My protocol had not yet found me.

1. Track your pattern. For one cycle (or one month, if your cycles have changed), jot down breast tenderness, anxiety spikes, sleep and caffeine reactions. Patterns are clues.
2. Try a caffeine-free week. Taper first so you skip the headache. Then notice your sleep, your heart rate and how fast you calm down after stress.
3. Read your supplement labels. Look for “folic acid,” the synthetic form. Methylfolate is the active form your methylation pathway can actually use [6]. Ask your provider which is right for you.
4. Give your magnesium some love. Many women run low, and COMT needs it to do its job. The one I recommend is Magnesium Breakthrough by BiOptimizers, because it blends seven different forms, and each form has its own strengths:
Different forms are absorbed and used in different ways, so a blend covers more bases than a single form. You’ll find it in my shop: Magnesium Breakthrough. As always, check with your provider before adding a new supplement.
5. Ask how you clear your hormones, not just your levels. At your next appointment, try this question: “Can we look at how I clear my hormones, not just how much I have?” Then watch the reaction.
(Between you and me, that question is exactly why I pair DNA and DUTCH testing for my clients. One shows the blueprint. The other shows it in action.)
For the roughly 30% of women who are highly sensitive [7].
You are the one who hears the hum of the refrigerator.
The one who feels the tension in a room before anyone speaks.
The one who needs a full day to recover from a holiday party everyone else bounced right back from.
Sensitivity has a biology.
A highly sensitive nervous system (what researchers call Sensory Processing Sensitivity) processes more input, more deeply [8]. That means it sets off your stress chemistry more often.
Now picture slow COMT on top of that. More adrenaline gets made, and it clears more slowly.
And one 2011 brain study found that people with two slow copies of COMT showed weaker “sensory gating,” the brain’s filter that screens out background noise [9]. So more of the world may get through.
That’s how you end up feeling it at a 10 when others feel it at a 4.
That’s not drama. That’s a nervous system and a gene doing exactly what they were built to do.
And once you know it, you can give your body the support, and the margin, it has always needed.
If this isn’t you, please pass it along to someone who comes to mind.
Sensitive. Seen. Supported.
For the women who refuse to let their lifespan outrun their vitality span,
Lori Finlay, NP, CNS
P.S. Want the deeper picture? I’ve put together The Science Behind Your Sensitivity, a plain-English guide that walks through your stress chemistry, COMT, MTHFR and glutathione side by side: what you feel on one side, why it’s happening on the other. Reply or comment “SENSITIVE” and I’ll send it to you.
P.P.S. Ready to connect your own dots? Book your Free Clarity Call at ConsultLori.com. Thirty minutes. No pressure. No pitch. Just clarity.
Coming next week: MTHFR, the supply chain that keeps COMT running.
A note on links: I’m an affiliate for Magnesium Breakthrough and DNA Company, which means if you purchase through my link, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only bring you products I have actually researched and use.
This content is for educational purposes only and is not medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Please talk with your healthcare provider before changing supplements or medications.